Anglican Mainsteam today highlights this story from breakpoint.org about one teenager’s court battle to defend her right to wear a t-shirt bearing the slogan ‘Be Happy Not Gay’ which brought her into conflict with her school. This story is unremarkable in itself (many similar stories of the alleged repression of Christians are highlighted weekly on Anglican Mainstream), however one line is typically infuriating:
“In effect, the school has outlawed Christian beliefs and free speech.”
Which implies that all Christians have the same beliefs which, on this issue, we absolutely and undeniably do not . These beliefs are not ‘Christian beliefs’, they are the beliefs of many Christians*. Not the same thing at all. It is the resolute and stubborn refusal to accept that not all Christians share the same viewpoint that makes this issue so heated – there is nothing more anger inducing than the feeling that however much you try to lead a Godly life, you are, and always will be, invalid in another’s sight and your beliefs, and the beliefs of those that support and love you, count for nothing, because your beliefs are not ‘Christian beliefs’. Believe me, being gay is easy to deal with in comparison to the crushing knowledge that other Christians find your relationship with God to be unpalatable and will do whatever they can to keep you in separation from Him.
* According to this page on the Fellowship of Independent Evangelical Churches site, the Evangelical Alliance survey of 21st Century Evangelicals found that 26% were “uncertain” or “disagreed” to some extent that homosexual actions are always wrong. This may be a minority, but it is nonetheless a significant number, especially as the survey is from a subset of Christians not noted for their liberal views.